Nick Shirley Exposes Food Stamp Fraud on Camera

A can of Spam and a tray of grocery store sushi shouldn't clear $100 anywhere in America, including Seattle. This week, Nick Shirley stood at a register in the city's Little Saigon neighborhood and watched that exact basket ring up to $120, payable with a food stamp card. "You made that $120?" Nick asks on camera, and the answer is, "Yeah."

Nick's new documentary, Inside the Food Stamp Fraud Scheme Stealing Billions, starts in a completely different manner than your typical investigation. He asks a man on a Seattle street how much lands on his food stamp card each month, and the man says $306. Nick asks what he would sell the card for in cash, and the man says $120. This practice is called SNAP trafficking, but more on that in the following article.

To catch a buyer, Nick needed a food stamp card of his own. He walked into the woods, into one of the encampments, and came out with several, something Seattle journalist Jonathan Choe says isn't hard to do. Choe tells Nick the cards turn up in almost every camp, sold, traded, or forgotten with money still on them. Another crew member compares them to Pokémon cards. A man living in the camp explains the rest to Nick: a buyer waits, picks out someone who needs cash more than groceries, and makes an offer.

Nick and two citizen journalists, Grant and Darren, then dressed down and walked toward 12th and Jackson, offering stamps for sale. A man on the corner gave them directions with the ease of a hotel concierge, down to which store to enter and to "talk to the lady." On their way, a woman stopped them on the sidewalk, asked how much was on the card, heard $120, and offered $60. She put Nick and Grant in the back of her minivan and drove them to the market herself.

Inside the store, which the video identifies as Lam's Seafood, the woman picked up a can of Spam and a package of sushi and took them to the register. The total was $120, matching what Nick's crew said was on the card. The card was declined on purpose as Nick didn’t want to commit actual fraud, but the store kept trying. Nick turned on his camera and told the woman she was committing fraud. She replied, "I know."

What happened next felt almost like a comedy sketch. In the middle of the confrontation, a shopper recognized Nick, said she was a big fan, and asked for a photo. Nick joked, "Mid fraud bust," and turned back to the Spam. The woman said she didn't work for anyone and was just buying food to take home. In his narration, Nick calls the operation a mafia-style ring and kept asking who gets the extra money, but no one answered. The woman pointed to someone else and said, "She buy too." Back inside, Nick asked the staff why Spam cost $120 and asked for a manager, but suddenly no one seemed to understand English.

Nick's day took another turn as he left the market and walked into a new emergency. While he was at the register, a fight broke out up the hill near Choe. According to Nick, a security guard working with Choe tackled a man, the guard's gun fell out, someone in the crowd grabbed it, and then the crowd turned on the crew. Nick's phone was off. The crew found him on the street. One of them called it God's grace, told him, "You're being targeted right now," and got everyone back to the van.

Keep reading to learn more about this SNAP trafficking down below.

We couldn’t do this without your support. Investigations, travel, and our team on the ground all exist because of you. We don’t take that for granted.

If you want to support our work, shop the Anti Fraud Taxpayer Club collection (& more). Every purchase directly fuels Nick Shirley’s future investigations.

If you’d like to support our mission for exposing fraud across the country, consider becoming a Founding Member today!

As a Founding Member, you’ll receive the core Anti Fraud Club articles, along with these benefits:

We truly appreciate your support and commitment to our mission.

Thank you.

What Nick Shirley filmed outside Lam’s Seafood in Seattle is actually very common and is referred to as a form of trafficking by the federal government. This market exists because of how the system is designed. A food stamp card can only buy food, while cash can buy anything. As a result, some people see their benefits as worth less than the amount shown on the card. For example, a buyer might offer $60 for a card with a $120 balance, and for someone who needs cash to buy drugs, that is enough.

To get cash, these fraudsters work with shops that appear legitimate to carry out their trafficking schemes. The United States Department of Agriculture reimburses authorized stores for whatever amount is charged to a card, so the checkout is where benefits turn into real money. Someone with another person’s card can buy groceries and resell them, or a store can process a fake sale, as Nick's footage shows.

For many years, food stamps were paper coupons that could be traded like cash. The USDA says switching to electronic cards, which was completed in every state by July 2004, helped reduce trafficking a lot. Unlike paper, a card requires a PIN and leaves a record of transactions. Each day, transaction records are sent to a USDA system called ALERT, which looks for patterns that might show trafficking. The department also conducts nearly 50,000 undercover store visits each year.

Federal law says that trafficking $100 or more in benefits is a felony. If the amount reaches $5,000, the penalty can be up to 20 years in prison and a $250,000 fine. Stores caught doing this can be permanently removed from the program. However, these punishments do not seem to stop the fraud. The USDA reports spending nearly $380 million a day on its nutrition programs, and Nick's documentary says food stamps alone cost over $100 billion a year. A USDA study from 2015 to 2017 found that 1.6 percent of benefits were trafficked, which is about $1.27 billion each year, and 12.7 percent of authorized stores were involved. The Government Accountability Office reviewed an earlier estimate and said the real number could be as high as $4.7 billion.

Since the Trump administration began, the USDA says it has disqualified or suspended almost 6,000 retailers and shut down more than 2,000 illegal card terminals. The department also takes anonymous tips, and its warning signs include stores that accept food stamps but do not actually sell food.

Nick Shirley posted his Seattle food stamp investigation on X this Wednesday. Elon Musk, who bought the platform in 2022, once told users, "You are the media now," and he supported Nick's reporting from the beginning. "I don't think too many people actually say thank you to Elon Musk," Nick told Shawn Ryan earlier this year, describing what it was like to meet Musk in person.

After Nick posted his 42-minute daycare video to X the day after Christmas, Musk shared it the next day and called for the governor to be prosecuted. Vice President JD Vance also reposted it, saying Nick had done "far more useful journalism" than any of the 2024 Pulitzer winners. Four days later, the Department of Health and Human Services froze all child care payments to Minnesota, and the deputy secretary mentioned Nick's video in the announcement.

The months that followed played out in a similar way. Nick spoke before a House Judiciary subcommittee on January 21, after Gov. Tim Walz dropped out of his reelection campaign. On March 16, President Trump signed an executive order to create the Task Force to Eliminate Fraud, led by Vance, and the fact sheet specifically mentioned Minnesota. Last Saturday, as Nick noted on Monday, the President asked Congress to require prison time for anyone who steals from Medicare, Medicaid, or Social Security.

Nick's videos on X now reach parts of the federal government that independent reporters couldn't access five or ten years ago. Americans shouldn't have to accept a country where fraudsters take from hardworking people and those who need help. More importantly, when independent journalists and content creators work together on platforms like X, they can build momentum that leaders will notice and act on.